Introduction: Keratomas are benign tumors made of keratin that develop inside the hoof capsule. They are rare in all equids, but when they occur, they can cause significant hoof problems if not detected and treated. In donkeys, hoof anatomy and behavior differences can make keratomas harder to recognize – donkeys have more upright, cylindrical hooves and often hide pain symptoms more than horses. As a result, a keratoma in a donkey may be overlooked until it causes chronic abscessing or lameness. This guide focuses on advanced detection methods, the pathophysiology of keratomas (and how donkeys might differ from horses), treatment options, addressing veterinary skepticism, the long-term impacts of leaving a keratoma untreated, key warning signs in detail, and ways hoof care providers can confidently identify and advocate for proper keratoma treatment.
Advanced Detection Techniques (Beyond Standard X-Rays)
Traditional radiographs (X-rays) are a common first step to investigate persistent hoof issues, but early or small keratomas may not be obvious on standard views. Often, only when the keratoma has grown enough to cause pressure erosion of the coffin bone will an X-ray reveal a characteristic smooth, circular or oval area of bone loss (lysis) on the distal phalanx.
Even then, radiographic signs can be subtle or confused with other problems like osteitis (infection of the bone). If a keratoma is suspected but not visible on plain films, advanced imaging provides better diagnostic power. Both computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) are highly effective at identifying keratomas inside the hoof capsule. These 3D imaging techniques show the soft-tissue mass and its exact size and position, which not only confirms the diagnosis but also helps in planning surgery. MRI, in particular, can detect keratomas of atypical appearance or in tricky locations that elude X-rays. CT scans can likewise pinpoint the lesion’s boundaries and any bone involvement, often allowing surgeons to minimize the hoof wall removal by targeting only the affected area.
In addition to high-tech imaging, hoof examination techniques are crucial. Careful visual inspection of the hoof can yield early clues: a keratoma often causes a noticeable change in the white line or sole. Farriers or trimmers may observe a well-circumscribed area on the sole where the white line is widened, distorted, or displaced. For example, a portion of the white line may appear to deviate inward toward the frog or have a gap/track that isn’t typical of normal hoof growth. Hoof testers are another invaluable tool – applying pressure with testers around the suspected area usually elicits a painful response if a keratoma is present.
Donkeys might be stoic, but a focused application of a hoof tester at the site of the lesion can still produce a flinch or withdrawal indicating pain. Another trick is percussive or thermal diagnostics: lightly tapping around the hoof wall may reveal a sensitive spot, and in some cases thermography (infrared imaging) could show a persistent hot spot from chronic inflammation. If lameness is localized to the foot (for instance, a palmar digital nerve block relieves the lameness, confirming the pain is in the hoof), and especially if there is a recurrent abscess tract in one location, a keratoma should be high on the list of differentials even if initial X-rays are clean. In summary, combining alternative imaging methods (CT, MRI, or ultrasound for superficial lesions) with thorough hoof testing and visual examination (white line and hoof wall inspection) greatly improves the chances of detecting a keratoma that might be missed by radiographs alone.
Pathophysiology: Formation and Progression (Donkeys vs. Horses)
Keratomas form from the keratin-producing epidermal cells of the hoof – essentially an abnormal mass of horn tissue that grows inward. Histologically, they consist of concentric rings of squamous epithelial cells filled with keratin, creating a firm but “soft” horn tumor. These typically develop between the inner hoof wall (stratum internum) and the coffin bone (third phalanx). As the keratoma slowly enlarges, it expands within the confined hoof capsule, exerting pressure on surrounding structures. The rigid hoof wall leaves the growing tumor no place to go but inward and downward, so it pushes against the sensitive laminae and can indent the surface of the coffin bone over time. This pressure causes the laminar connection between hoof wall and bone to separate or distort. In early stages, the keratoma may be small and cause no noticeable pain or infection – it could be “clinically inapparent” if it isn’t pressing on sensitive tissue. However, as it enlarges, two things usually happen: 1) it physically deforms the white line and sometimes even the outer hoof wall (causing bulges or rings), and 2) the abnormal horn tissue inside can degenerate or get infected, leading to abscess formation. In fact, keratomas often consist of poor-quality, crumbly horn that easily decays, providing a perfect hiding spot for bacteria or fungi. The result is a necrotic core or intermittent abscesses that track up along the path of least resistance (often breaking out at the coronet or sole).
The cause of keratoma formation is not fully understood. They are considered true tumors (benign and non-spreading), but unlike cancer, they don’t metastasize. Possible triggers include chronic irritation or trauma to the hoof’s germinal cells. Some cases seem to follow an injury or inflammation of the coronary band – for example, a hard blow or persistent crack at the coronet might damage the cells that produce the hoof wall, leading to abnormal keratin growth. Repeated hoof wall trauma (like sand cracks that never heal properly) has also been suggested as a culprit. In many instances, though, no definitive cause is found – it’s an idiopathic overgrowth of horn-producing cells. Interestingly, research in donkeys has noted a strong association with infection: in a study of 167 donkeys with keratomas, a significant number of keratoma specimens contained bacterial and fungal invaders. Specifically, degenerated keratin from donkey keratomas was often found harboring spiral bacteria (Treponema sp.) and fungal hyphae, whereas healthy donkey hoof samples did not. This suggests that chronic infection might play a role in the development or progression of keratomas in donkeys – or conversely, that keratomas create an environment prone to infection. Either way, donkeys in less-than-ideal hoof conditions (wet environments, chronic thrush or white line disease, etc.) might have a higher risk of keratoma formation due to ongoing hoof capsule irritation.
Differences between donkeys and horses: Donkeys share the same basic hoof anatomy as horses, but with some notable differences that can influence keratoma presentation. Donkey hooves are more upright and cylindrical, with a stronger digital cushion and often a thicker sole relative to hoof size. These differences mean a donkey’s hoof might not deform outward as readily under internal pressure – a keratoma might cause more subtle external changes. Additionally, donkeys are famously stoic; they tend to mask lameness or pain until it becomes quite severe. So a donkey could have a keratoma growing for a long time with only mild, intermittent signs that might be overlooked. In contrast, many horses would exhibit lameness or a noticeable change in the hoof earlier on. There is also a knowledge gap – historically, most keratoma literature is about horses, with little published data on donkeys. This lack of documentation may have led to underdiagnosis in donkeys. However, recent case series suggest that donkeys get keratomas in essentially the same way horses do, and they respond similarly to treatment. One difference that emerged from donkey studies is the high incidence of microorganisms found in the keratoma tissue (as mentioned above), which could mean donkey keratomas often have a concurrent infection component. Practically, this means that in donkeys we might see more abscess drainage associated with keratomas, and ensuring broad-spectrum antimicrobial coverage during treatment could be especially important. In summary, a keratoma’s pathophysiology – a benign keratin mass expanding in the hoof – is the same in donkeys and horses. The main distinctions lie in presentation: donkeys may show more subtle signs and possibly have a higher likelihood of infected keratomas, emphasizing the need for vigilant observation by caregivers.
Treatment Options: Surgery, Alternatives, and Recovery
Once a keratoma is confirmed or strongly suspected and causing problems, surgical removal is the treatment of choice in both horses and donkeys. Because a keratoma is a physical mass of abnormal tissue, it must be excised to relieve the pressure and resolve the issue; there are no medications or trims alone that can eliminate the tumor. The surgery involves removing the section of hoof capsule overlying the keratoma and cutting out the keratin mass, while preserving as much healthy tissue as possible. Depending on the location of the keratoma, the surgeon may approach it from the sole or via a partial hoof wall resection from the front/side of the hoof. For example, a keratoma under the toe may be accessed by going through the sole, whereas one higher up under the hoof wall might require taking out a window of the hoof wall.
The procedure can often be done on a standing animal with heavy sedation and a regional nerve block (e.g. a tourniquet and local anesthetic to numb the foot). Standing surgery avoids the risks of general anesthesia, which is a consideration especially in donkeys and mules that can be sensitive to anesthesia. However, if the keratoma is extensive or the donkey is not amenable to restraint, general anesthesia may be used for better control and sterility. A tourniquet on the limb is typically applied to minimize bleeding during the hoof wall resection, since the hoof is well-perfused and can bleed profusely when the wall is cut. The surgeon will make one or two vertical (or arched) cuts through the hoof wall around the affected area and then pry out that section of hoof wall, exposing the keratoma beneath. The abnormal keratoma tissue is then carefully excised, often by curettage (scraping) or using small hoof knives or motorized burrs to peel it away from the adjacent laminae. The texture of keratoma tissue is distinctive – veterinarians describe it as having a cheesy or rubbery consistency (one vet noted it “often has a texture like parmesan cheese” when cut out). Removing it entirely is crucial; any remnants could lead to regrowth. The exposed space (defect) left in the hoof is essentially like a large V-shaped or rectangular notch either in the sole or wall.
After removal, post-surgical care is vital for healing and preventing complications. The surgical site is packed with sterile gauze soaked in antiseptic and the hoof is bandaged securely. Often, a special protective device called a hospital plate is applied – this is a metal plate that can be screwed onto a custom shoe or cuff, covering the sole to keep dirt out but removable for bandage changes. In a hoof wall approach, the vet and farrier may apply a bar shoe with side clips or other stabilization before or just after surgery to keep the remaining hoof wall from splaying apart. In donkeys, if the hoof is small, sometimes a cast or boot is used instead for stability. The animal is started on antibiotics and anti-inflammatories to ward off infection and manage pain. Bandage changes are done every 2–3 days initially, replacing the antiseptic gauze until a dry layer of new cornified tissue starts to form over the wound. The goal is to have the defect fill in with healthy horn from the coronary band downward and from the surrounding laminae inward. This healing is by “second intention,” meaning no stitches are placed – the hoof will regenerate the gap over time.
Hoof wall growth is slow (approximately 6 mm per month), so complete regrowth of the removed section can take many months. Typically, it might be 8–12 months before the hoof is fully restored and normal, especially if the keratoma was near the coronet and a full hoof-wall length has to grow out. During this time, the donkey needs regular hoof care and possibly special shoeing or boots to support the healing area. Farriers often use a heart bar or full-bar shoe to distribute weight away from the resected area, or they may apply acrylic or epoxy hoof repair material after a few weeks to brace the gap once there’s some new tissue covering the sensitive parts. Strict stall rest or limited movement is recommended in the early weeks until the hoof stabilizes, and the animal should be kept on clean, dry bedding to prevent contamination of the wound. With proper care, the prognosis after complete surgical excision is generally excellent – most animals return to soundness once the hoof defect grows out. A study on donkeys with keratoma-like lesions showed that after surgical removal, all the treated donkeys recovered and became sound, with no deaths or career-ending issues. Horses show similarly good outcomes, with one review finding the majority of cases healed without complication when the entire keratoma was removed.
Are there alternative treatments? In truth, there is no non-surgical way to remove a keratoma. However, in cases where the keratoma is not causing lameness or abscessing (incidental finding), a conservative approach might be taken. Some veterinarians and farriers will opt to monitor a small keratoma and only intervene if it grows or starts causing pain. Because the surgery involves creating a hoof defect, if an animal is completely comfortable and the keratoma is very small, one might choose to leave it alone for a while. Regular radiographs could track its size. In a few reported cases, simply keeping the hoof balanced and supported with a shoe prevented any lameness, allowing the horse to work normally despite the keratoma. This “watchful waiting” approach is only for asymptomatic cases – the moment there are repeated abscesses or pain, active treatment is needed. Another scenario is if the animal’s health or other factors make surgery very risky (for instance, an elderly donkey that can’t undergo anesthesia). In such a case, palliative care might include frequent abscess drainage, aggressive infection control, and shoeing adjustments to relieve pressure. These measures might prolong comfort for a time, but they do not remove the underlying tumor, so they’re not a cure. There has also been discussion in veterinary circles about less invasive techniques like laser ablation of keratomas or dissolving them with enzymes, but these are experimental at best and not widely documented.
In summary, surgical excision is the definitive treatment for keratomas, with a high success rate. The keys to treatment are complete removal of the keratin mass, meticulous hoof care during healing, and patience while the hoof regenerates. Post-op, hoof care providers play a big role in trimming and shoeing to support the hoof. It’s also worth noting that keratomas, while benign, can recur if any abnormal tissue remains or if the initiating cause (like a chronic coronet injury) isn’t resolved. Fortunately, recurrence is uncommon when surgery is done properly. With attentive follow-up, most donkeys and horses go on to have normal use of their hoof after the year-long recovery period.
Veterinary Skepticism and Advocacy: Overcoming Dismissal of Keratomas
One challenge hoof care professionals often face is that keratomas can be easy to dismiss or misdiagnose, especially in the early stages. There are a few reasons for this. First, keratomas are relatively rare; many equine veterinarians may go their whole career seeing only a handful of cases. When a donkey presents with hoof pain or recurrent abscesses, the typical assumption is an ordinary sole abscess, bruise, or perhaps laminitis – not a tumor. If an X-ray doesn’t clearly show a keratoma, a vet might conclude there’s nothing major going on. In fact, standard radiographs can be inconclusive: a small keratoma often won’t show any bone changes, and the soft tissue mass itself isn’t visible on X-ray. The subtle white line deviations might be chalked up to minor white line disease or an old abscess tract. Thus, a cycle can emerge where the donkey is treated repeatedly for abscesses or “mystery lameness” without ever addressing the root cause.
Another factor is that a definitive diagnosis of keratoma requires either advanced imaging or histopathology (lab analysis of the tissue). Vets are understandably hesitant to cut into a hoof or recommend expensive CT/MRI scans without strong justification. If the lameness is intermittent and the animal improves after each abscess drains, it might seem reasonable to adopt a wait-and-see approach. Additionally, in some regions, access to advanced imaging or specialized surgeons might be limited, so general practitioners may not readily pursue that route. There can also be a mentality of “if it’s not on the X-ray, it’s not there,” which we know isn’t true for keratomas. This skepticism is compounded in donkeys by their stoicism – a donkey might not appear extremely lame, so the vet (or owner) may not feel the issue is severe enough to warrant invasive diagnostics. The result is that hoof care providers who suspect a keratoma can sometimes face an uphill battle convincing others of its presence.
So how can we push through limitations in veterinary diagnostics and advocate for the animal? Hoof care providers are often the first to notice something like a keratoma, since they see the feet regularly and in detail. If you, as a farrier or trimmer, observe the telltale signs (like a consistent white line deviation or a recurring abscess at the same spot), don’t hesitate to voice your concern. Provide the veterinarian with a clear history and evidence: “This donkey has had an abscess in the exact same location three times in six months,” or “I’ve noticed this odd bulge in the white line that hasn’t grown out.” Such specifics can prompt a vet to take a closer look. Cite the patterns known in keratoma cases – for instance, the Merck Veterinary Manual notes that recurrent foot abscesses in the same location are common in horses with keratomas. Bringing up this kind of authoritative reference can lend weight to your observations. If radiographs have been taken and are inconclusive, suggest the next steps: “I understand the X-ray didn’t show much; however, keratomas often don’t show until they’re large. Perhaps we could do a different angle or consider an MRI, or even a small exploratory hoof wall resection to confirm.” In other words, encourage the veterinarian to either pursue advanced imaging or a minor diagnostic procedure (like removing a tiny bit of hoof under local anesthesia to inspect the area or take a biopsy).
It’s also helpful to remind the veterinary team that a negative X-ray doesn’t rule out a keratoma. Vets know this, but a gentle nudge can refocus the diagnostic process. Some published case reports emphasize that when there is persistent, unexplained hoof lameness or abscessing, a keratoma should be considered even if initial diagnostics are unrevealing. You might share such a case or article summary with a vet who is skeptical. In doing so, approach the topic collaboratively – for example: “I recently read a case study where a horse had intermittent lameness and it turned out to be a keratoma that only showed up on an MRI. Maybe that’s something to think about here.” This way you’re not undermining the vet but offering additional information.
If cost or access to advanced diagnostics is a limiting factor, discuss alternatives. Perhaps a referral to an equine hospital for a CT scan is possible, or if not, a compromise might be to treat it as if it’s a keratoma (with surgery) based on strong clinical suspicion. Sometimes the true diagnosis is only confirmed during surgery when the mass is removed and sent for histology. As a hoof care provider, you can advocate by preparing the owner for this possibility – explain that pursuing definitive treatment might be the best course for the donkey’s welfare, even if it seems extreme. Emphasize the long-term consequences of leaving a keratoma (outlined in the next section) to highlight why taking action is important.
Lastly, remember that veterinarians are scientists at heart – they respond to evidence. Whenever possible, collect and present evidence: photographs of the white line lesion, dates and descriptions of each abscess incident, and your objective findings (hoof tester sensitivity, etc.). A clear timeline or log can illustrate the pattern that might otherwise be missed. By being persistent, factual, and cooperative, hoof care providers can help overcome initial skepticism. It may take some perseverance – you might hear, “It’s just another abscess,” but if you truly suspect a keratoma, continue to monitor and bring it up. Your advocacy can lead to earlier intervention, which will greatly benefit the donkey in the long run.
Long-Term Impact of Untreated Keratomas
Leaving a keratoma untreated is not a benign neglect; over time, the condition will almost always worsen and can seriously compromise the hoof. Mechanically, as the keratoma enlarges, it will further separate the hoof wall from the coffin bone. This creates a widening pocket that weakens the structural integrity of the hoof. The hoof wall may start to deform – you might see a persistent bulge or even a vertical crack develop in the hoof wall over the tumor. If the keratoma runs down the front, a visible indent or groove can appear, sometimes giving the hoof a distorted shape. This damage to the hoof capsule means the donkey’s weight distribution in that foot becomes abnormal, potentially leading to additional issues like overloading the opposite side of the hoof or the other limbs.
Internally, constant pressure can cause bone remodeling or destruction. The coffin bone (P3) can develop a concave notch where the keratoma presses; essentially the tumor “eats into” the bone by pressure necrosis. On radiographs of chronic cases, you’ll see a smoothly marginated area of bone loss where the keratoma was seated. If the keratoma continues to expand, this bone loss can progress to the point of weakening the coffin bone or even penetrating into the bone’s sensitive interior (which could lead to infection of the bone, known as septic pedal osteitis). An untreated keratoma that becomes infected is a ticking time bomb – the infection can track upward and potentially invade the coffin joint or create a chronic draining tract at the coronary band. In donkeys, a chronically infected keratoma might be mistaken for white line disease or gravel, but unlike those conditions, it will not resolve with topical treatments or trimming because the keratoma tissue keeps feeding the infection.
The consequences for the donkey’s health and comfort are significant. Recurrent abscesses are painful episodes; a donkey may go through cycles of acute pain (during abscess build-up) and relief (after drainage) repeatedly. This chronic pain and inflammation can cause them to lose body condition, become depressed, or reduce their mobility. Donkeys already are prone to conditions like hyperlipaemia when stressed and in pain, so ongoing hoof pain can indirectly lead to metabolic problems from reduced appetite. Lameness that fluctuates but gradually worsens will eventually limit the donkey’s ability to move and graze normally. The animal may start to put more weight on the other limbs to compensate, raising the risk of supporting limb laminitis or overuse injuries in those limbs. In extreme long-term cases, a donkey with an untreated keratoma might suffer permanent hoof capsule damage or coffin bone deformity that even surgery later cannot fully fix. For example, if a large section of coffin bone has been eroded away, the hoof might remain unstable or the animal might always have a degree of lameness. There’s also the risk that what was once a benign keratoma can set the stage for chronic infection that becomes systemic. While keratomas themselves don’t metastasize, an untreated one could potentially lead to bone infection serious enough to be life-threatening or necessitate euthanasia (though that is a worst-case scenario).
In donkeys, where lameness signs might be subtle, the keratoma might quietly cause significant hoof architecture damage before anyone realizes the extent. By the time it’s obvious, you could have a donkey with a major hoof wall deficit and a severe bone lesion. This is why early detection and treatment are so important. If treated early, the hoof can heal with minor changes; if treated very late, the hoof might never return to full normal shape even if the keratoma is removed. Long-term, a neglected keratoma can also result in arthritis in adjacent joints (coffin or pastern joint) due to altered gait, or tendon issues from the donkey compensating how it bears weight.
On the flip side, the long-term outlook after proper keratoma removal is very good. Once the tumor is gone and the hoof grows back, the donkey can usually resume normal activities without pain. The key is preventing that irreversible damage by not delaying intervention. Hoof care providers should communicate that while an untreated keratoma might not kill the donkey outright, it will steadily deteriorate hoof function and quality of life. It’s far better to deal with it sooner than later, to avoid the cascade of secondary problems (chronic infection, bone loss, deformity, etc.). In summary, an untreated keratoma acts like a slow-expanding wedge in the hoof – causing progressive structural damage, intermittent pain spikes, and providing a haven for infections. The longer it’s left, the harder it can be to fully restore the hoof to health.
Key Indicators of Keratomas (Early Warning Signs Explained)
Early recognition of a keratoma often hinges on a few hallmark signs. These are clues that hoof care providers should be vigilant about, especially in donkeys that might not overtly limp at first. The key indicators include:
- White Line Displacement or Distorted Lesion: One of the primary early warning signs of a keratoma is a lesion that displaces the white line. In practical terms, this means the white line on the sole doesn’t look normal in one area – it may bulge inward, widen, or form an abnormal shape right at the junction where the hoof wall meets the sole. This happens because the keratoma, growing between the hoof wall and bone, pushes the laminae apart, and that disturbance shows up at the bottom of the foot. Farriers often notice that the white line deviates toward the center of the sole around the keratoma, sometimes curving in a semicircle behind the tumor’s location. It can look like a hollow or stretched white line segment. In some cases, there might be a small separation or pocket forming at the white line – as the keratoma grows downward, it can eventually cause the white line to actually separate (almost like the start of a cavity or tunnel). This sign is subtle but significant. Unlike generalized white line disease (which usually affects multiple areas and appears crumbly or fungal), a keratoma-related white line defect is typically localized and well-circumscribed. It might have a smooth, rounded outline corresponding to the shape of the keratoma pressing outward. If you see a peculiar stretch or bend in the white line that isn’t typical, take note – especially if it persists trim after trim without growing out. This is often the earliest visible clue to a keratoma, appearing even before the animal becomes lame. Also watch for any bulge at the coronary band directly above that area; sometimes a keratoma causes a slight coronary band swelling or a palpable bump if it’s near the top of the hoof. Essentially, any unusual lesion at the white line that remains in the same spot over time warrants further investigation.
A donkey’s hoof showing abnormal displacement of the white line (red arrow) due to a keratoma growing beneath the hoof wall. Such an inward deviation or bulge of the white line is often the first visible sign of a keratoma.
.
-
Chronic or Intermittent Abscessing: Keratomas and recurrent hoof abscesses often go hand-in-hand. If you encounter chronic or intermittent abscessing in the same area of the hoof, it’s a big red flag for a keratoma. What happens is the keratoma creates a gap between the hoof wall and the bone, as mentioned, and that gap can get infected. Each time an abscess forms, it may follow the path along the keratoma’s edge and eventually rupture out (through the coronet or sole), relieving pressure temporarily. But because the underlying cause (the keratoma tissue) is still there, bacteria can re-enter and the abscess can recur. You might notice a cycle: the donkey gets sore, an abscess is drained or bursts, the donkey improves for a few weeks, then lameness returns with another abscess in the exact same spot. In a typical hoof abscess from a one-time injury, you wouldn’t expect it to come back repeatedly in the same location. Thus, this pattern of repeat abscesses is highly indicative of a space-occupying lesion like a keratoma.
Often the abscesses are along the white line or at the coronary band corresponding to where the keratoma is causing separation. During these abscess episodes, you might find pus at the white line or draining at the coronet. In fact, if you see pus erupting right at the white line/sole junction or from the top of the hoof without an obvious sole puncture, consider that it might be tracking along a keratoma’s path. Another clue is that the abscesses might contain bits of white/grey cheesy material – possibly fragments of keratoma debris. Recurrent subsolar or submural abscessation has been directly linked to keratomas in the literature. Differentiating these from standard hoof infections comes down to repetition and location. A “one-off” abscess that heals is likely just an abscess; an abscess that keeps coming back in one quarter or toe region suggests an underlying keratoma or other persistent issue. Hoof care providers should track where on the hoof each abscess occurs. If it’s always the same quadrant, you have reason to be suspicious. Keep in mind that while treating the abscess (e.g. draining and poulticing) will give short-term relief, the problem will not fully resolve until the keratoma is addressed. So, chronic abscessing is both a key indicator and a complication of keratomas – it’s often what finally triggers further diagnostics. As one farrier succinctly put it, “repeat abscesses must have a cause”, and a keratoma is often the hidden cause in these stubborn cases.
-
Progressive, Fluctuating Lameness: Lameness caused by a keratoma often has a waxing and waning quality that can confuse diagnosis. Early on, a donkey might only be a bit short-strided or occasionally “off” on the affected hoof, perhaps only when making sharp turns or on hard ground. The lameness may seem to come and go, which often coincides with the abscess pattern – worse during an abscess, better after it drains. This intermittent nature can lead one to think the issue has resolved, only for the lameness to flare up again. Over time, as the keratoma grows, the lameness tends to become more frequent and more severe overall. You may notice that each episode of soreness is a little worse or lasts a little longer than the previous. The term progressive lameness is used because eventually the discomfort increases to the point of persistent lameness that won’t fully go away. It’s also notable that keratoma-related lameness often doesn’t follow a clear injury – the donkey wasn’t acutely hurt, it just started getting lame gradually. Observers might see a mystery lameness that improves with standard abscess treatment or rest, but then inexplicably returns. This progression happens because the keratoma is slowly enlarging and causing more pressure. What’s tricky is that in the early phase, radiographs might show nothing abnormal despite the recurring lameness. This is why you can have a donkey whose X-rays are “clean” but it continues to go lame – the keratoma hasn’t yet caused bone changes or is positioned in a way that escaped the X-ray detection. As hoof care professionals, trust the clinical picture: lameness that keeps coming back in the same foot, especially paired with those abscesses or white line changes, is a strong indicator even if imaging hasn’t caught up to it. The lameness might also fluctuate with the size of the keratoma – for instance, some keratomas grow very slowly and the animal might be mostly sound for months, whereas a faster-growing keratoma or one in a critical spot (like pressing on the toe region) might cause a quicker decline in soundness. Also, donkeys may show lameness in subtle ways: maybe just reluctance to move out or a slight head bob at the trot that comes and goes. Over time, you might see secondary signs like the donkey preferring to load the heel more to take pressure off the toe (if the keratoma is at the toe), or an altered stance. In any case, worsening lameness over time, even if intermittently improving, should raise suspicion of a keratoma once other common causes are ruled out. Remember that a consistent trend of decline, however slow, is key – it differentiates a keratoma from something like a simple abscess (which once drained, should resolve lameness completely and not return). If a radiograph eventually does show the keratoma, it often correlates with this advanced stage when lameness is pronounced. But you don’t need to wait for that visual proof if all the signs point towards a keratoma. Progressive lameness that defies normal treatment is the hoof’s way of telling us to look deeper.
Empowering Hoof Care Providers: Recognition and Advocacy
For farriers and trimmers, confidently recognizing a keratoma without immediate radiographic proof comes down to combining knowledge with keen observation. As we’ve outlined, there are distinctive patterns – a displaced white line, repeated abscesses, a gradually worsening limp – that shout “keratoma” when they all line up. Hoof care providers should trust their educated instincts in these cases. You are the professional regularly working on that donkey’s feet, and you likely have the best opportunity to notice early changes. Here are some actionable steps to empower you in recognizing and advocating for keratoma cases:
-
Know the Signs and Document Them: Keep a mental (or written) checklist of the key indicators and examine suspect hooves closely at each visit. If you see a white line deviation or a hoof wall crack that isn’t typical, make note of its size and position. Use your hoof knife to gently explore any small tracts or separations – do they follow a circular path or lead to a focal spot of crumbly horn? When an abscess is opened, observe its track; does it seem to originate from a wall/laminar separation rather than a sole bruise? Write down each occurrence of abscess or lameness with dates. Taking photos is extremely helpful: a sole photo showing the white line lesion, or a picture of the drainage at the coronet can be powerful evidence. Over time, these records can clearly show a pattern that might otherwise be dismissed as random bad luck. This documentation will strengthen your case when talking to vets or owners.
-
Use Hoof Testers and Palpation: Make hoof testers your routine, especially if you suspect a keratoma. Check the same spots each time – is there consistent pain at, say, the toe-quarter junction on the lateral side? Consistent pain on the tester in a specific area, visit after visit, is not normal and should be pursued. Also feel the coronary band for any unusual swelling or heat. Sometimes you can even detect a slight give or soft spot in the hoof wall if the keratoma has caused wall thinning (less common, but noteworthy if present). These hands-on findings can be reported to the vet as objective data: e.g. “Hoof testers always elicit a response at 10 o’clock on the LF hoof.”
-
Educate the Owner (and Vet): Often, as the hoof care provider, you act as a liaison between the horse/donkey owner and the veterinarian. Owners might not know what a keratoma is, and vets might underestimate it initially. Take time to explain to the owner in clear terms why you suspect a keratoma: “We’ve treated three abscesses in the same spot. That usually means there’s something inside the hoof causing them. One possibility is a keratoma, which is a benign tumor inside the hoof.” Owners who understand the seriousness (but treatability) of the condition are more likely to authorize further diagnostics or treatment. When speaking with the vet, use a professional and collaborative tone. You might say: “During trimming I noticed the white line in this donkey’s foot is displaced in a way I’ve seen with keratomas in the past, and given the recurring abscesses, I’m concerned there might be one.” Point them to specific references if needed (since vets appreciate evidence): for example, mention that textbooks like Merck Manual cite a distorted white line as the initial sign of keratoma and recurrent abscesses as a common history. By doing so, you’re not just giving an opinion – you’re backing it up with established knowledge.
-
Advocate for Diagnostic Confirmation: If the vet hasn’t already, encourage getting radiographs – and ensure they know exactly where your concern is so they can target that area (maybe a different angle or a close-up view of the toe). If radiographs are inconclusive and the signs persist, discuss advanced imaging or referral. Sometimes a vet may need a little nudge to suggest an MRI or CT to the owner, since these can be expensive. You can help by emphasizing the payoff: “An MRI could tell us definitively if there’s a keratoma, which would then guide proper treatment and finally stop these abscess cycles.” If advanced imaging isn’t an option, ask if the vet would consider an exploratory hoof wall resection under local block – essentially a minor surgery to open the area and see if a keratoma is present (and if so, remove it on the spot). This can be a more budget-friendly diagnostic-treatment combo. As a farrier, you might offer to be on hand to apply a shoe or support during such a procedure, showing the vet and owner that you’re invested in a successful outcome.
-
Support the Treatment and Recovery: Once a keratoma is diagnosed and surgery planned, your role is crucial. Work with the vet to prepare the hoof – often the farrier will be asked to apply a shoe (with clips or a bar) before the surgery to stabilize the hoof capsule. Be ready to do this, and ensure the shoe is shaped to avoid pressure under the area to be resected. After surgery, assist with or handle the protective shoeing or casting that’s needed. Your expertise in keeping the hoof balanced while a section is missing is invaluable. Also, plan a trim/shoeing schedule during recovery that aligns with veterinary check-ups. By taking an active part in the treatment process, you reinforce the team approach and underscore the importance of proper hoof care in healing.
-
Keep Communication Open and Confidence High: It can be intimidating to push a diagnosis when you are not the veterinarian, but remember that your observations are a critical part of the diagnostic puzzle. Approach the conversation with confidence in what you see. The more cases you encounter (or even read about), the more your confidence will grow. If a vet dismisses the idea initially, don’t be discouraged. Continue to monitor and if the problem persists, bring it up again – “I know we talked about this before, but this is now the fourth abscess; I really think we should revisit the keratoma possibility.” Most vets will appreciate your diligence, as long as it’s clear the motivation is the donkey’s well-being and not ego. In tricky cases, you can also seek out advice from equine podiatry specialists or share case details (respectfully and anonymously) in professional farrier/vet forums – someone might have dealt with a similar case and can offer pointers that you can then relay.
In essence, empowerment comes from knowledge and collaboration. By understanding keratomas thoroughly (as you now do) and carefully observing each hoof you work on, you become the first line of defense against this sneaky condition. When you do suspect a keratoma, use that knowledge to advocate for the donkey: communicate clearly with owners and vets, provide evidence, and be willing to assist in any further diagnostics or treatment steps. Many keratomas are only definitively diagnosed because a persistent hoof care provider kept looking for answers. Your advocacy can be the difference between a donkey suffering through months of unresolved pain versus getting the curative treatment it needs. Stay proactive, trust your eyes and experience, and you will be a powerful voice in ensuring keratomas are no longer dismissed, but addressed promptly for the sake of the animal.
Conclusion: Keratomas in donkeys may be uncommon and easily overlooked, but with advanced detection techniques and informed hoof care providers, they can be identified and resolved. Remember the core points: look beyond radiographs if lameness persists, understand how and why a keratoma forms (so you can explain it to others), know that surgery is effective and necessary in most cases, and don’t let initial skepticism deter you from pursuing the issue. By catching the key indicators – a displaced white line, recurrent abscesses, and progressive lameness – you can initiate the proper care early. Donkeys rely on us to notice the subtle warnings they give. Armed with this knowledge and a collaborative mindset, hoof care professionals can ensure that donkeys with keratomas get timely, effective treatment and go on to live comfortable, sound lives.
Sources:
- Merck Veterinary Manual – Keratomas in Horses .
- Foundation Equine Wellness – Keratoma Client Education .
- The Donkey Sanctuary – Thiemann, A.K. Hoof surgery in donkeys – results of 24 cases .
- Paraschou, G. et al. 2023 – Treponema spp. spirochetes and keratinopathogenic fungi in donkey keratomas (Vet Pathology) .
- Mad Barn (Equine Nutrition) – Keratomas in Horses: Lameness Causing Foot Tumors .
- Vetster (Dr. M. Ricard) – Keratomas in Horses – Causes, Treatment and Conditions .
- Butler Farrier School Blog – Keratoma (Pete Butler, 2019) .
- Summerveld Equine Hospital – Solar Keratoma: An Atypical Case (2018) .
- American Farriers Journal – Recurrent Abscesses Result from Keratoma (illustrative context).
- Research on Donkey Pain – Donkeys hide pain more than horses .
